Skip to main content

Are Young Adult Books Too Dark?

I have read the book Speak and The Diary of a Part-Time Indian and I liked both of them. I read them in high school my freshman year.  I found The Diary of a Part-time Indian to be more interesting though. In case you don't know these books, Speak is about a girl named Melinda who is too scared to tell her story about being raped at the beginning of the summer. She spends most of her time in the janitor's closet and drawing trees in art class. Over the course of the book, Melinda goes through some rough times but eventually comes to terms with what had happened that summer. The Diary of a Part-Time Indian is about a young boy named Junior. He is fourteen and lives on the spokesman Indian reservation in Washington Junior really likes drawing cartoons. It will be his first year attending a school of their reservation but things don't go as planned. Junior gets bullied and his life starts to go downhill,  family and friendships are torn apart and people die. Junior learns that drinking isn't a way to solve all your problems either.

In Alexie Sherman's "why the best books are written in blood", Alexie talked about a young man, "he was seventeen and destined to join the military. Yes, he was old enough to die and kill for his country. And old enough to experience the infinite horrors. But according to Ms.Gurdon, he might be too young to read a YA novel that vividly portrays those very same horrors"(Sherman).  I thought that this was a very interesting point because it shows that stuff that happens in books isn't all lies, parts of it are real. In that boy's case, I feel like he should be allowed to read those types of books because he might go through some of the same struggles later in life. I do agree with the fact that the best books are books written by people who have experience. It makes the book more relatable to others who have gone through events.

In the reading of "Darkness to Visible", there were some great points brought up. One that really hit me was how dark things have gotten in books. an example that was used was Andrew Smith's novel in 2010, "young Jack is drugged and abducted and nearly raped by a male captor. After escaping, he encounters a curious pair of classes that transport him into an alternate world of almost unimaginable gore and cruelty. Moments after arriving he finds himself facing a wall of horrors". To me, I don't understand how someone could read this, let alone write it. This is an example of too much darkness. Young adults don't need to be reading about that dark of stuff. I think at a point there is such thing as too much darkness in Young Adult books. If a book is too dark Young Adults might take the meaning of the book in the wrong way and I think at some point, yes, it could hurt their mental health.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Children of the Holocaust - Gisella Renate Berg

Initial Post:  Hello, My name is Gisella Berg. I was on May 1, 1933, in a small village in Germany. I live with my parents, my sister, Igne, and my grandparents. My father worked as a cattle dealer and worked with jews and non-jew. My parents never let me go outside to play, they said it was too dangerous and they wanted to keep me safe. One day when I  was 5 there was an event that happened called the night of the broken glass. I didn't go through it but a friend told my family about it. My family was scared. In May 1939 after I turned 6 we fled to Kenya for safety. When we got to Kenya I was still able to continue being educated with my sister. In 1947 we moved to the United States where my family started their own chicken farm. I got my high school diploma and in 1957 I married a man named Kurt Pauly who also had fled from Germany. Responses:  Hi Gisella, I am glad your family was able to flee Germany and survive the war. My daughter and I also survived the war, but th...
Post a Comment
Read more

Most important Quotes in The Book Thief

One quote that I really liked was "I wanted to tell the book thief many things, about beauty and brutality. But what could I tell her about those things that she didn't already know? I wanted to explain that I am constantly overestimating and underestimating the human race—that rarely do I ever simply estimate it. I wanted to ask her how the same thing could be so ugly and so glorious, and its words and stories so damning and brilliant"( Zusak 550).   This is at the very ending of the book but I feel it sums up the story well. Death is telling the story and that's one thing I kind of like. I like that it's narrated by someone who isn't necessarily human but an outlook. We have talked a lot about how death is human and how he doesn't understand what is happening and how humanity can be this way. I think this quote is great because it shows how proud of Lisel he is. After this quote death goes on to say "None of those things, however, came out of my mou...
Post a Comment
Read more

Rite of Passage

Rite of passage from childhood to adulthood Organization  are you able to find most things in your house or are there things very hidden where you could forget that they are there Respectfulness  Are you able to talk to an adult respectfully (if needed, there is going to be humor and not all of it is serious) (Not being sassy towards someone)   Time Management  Do you know when things are and how long it will take to get to them  Money  Do you have money management ideas/skills? I think it's hard to become an adult and that there are so many factors that go into it.  I'm considered an adult because I am over 18 but I don't feel like one. When I think of being an adult I think a lot about responsibility, money, having a job, being organized, and lots more. I think even as adults people don't always have these things. I think I'm thinking too much and this is more of someone who is going from their upper teen years, maybe the second half of high sch...
Post a Comment
Read more